About the Apple Pencil

It’s not the best stylus experience ever. Just the best on an Apple device.

I had a Microsoft Surface Pro 2 for a while. That was the last Surface model that had a Wacom stylus digitizer. It was awesome. The default Surface stylus was alright, in the same way that the Apple Pencil is alright. But then I picked up this Bamboo stylus from Wacom.

  
I don’t think they sell it any more. 

Writing and drawing on the Surface Pro 2 with that stylus is the best stylus experience ever. In fact, writing on any Wacom-based digitizing surface with that stylus is great, even something like that Asus VivoTab Note 8, which is a great little Windows tablet that punches well above its weight.

 
I don’t think you can buy it any more, though. Too bad. It’s one of those devices that never got the attention it deserved, especially considering it cost under $300.

Anyway, the Apple Pencil.

It needs one of these things.

  
 Yeah, that’s one of those cheap rubber pencil holder things that kids use in grade school. It needs one because the shaft is altogether too smooth and narrow. Apple may have done that on purpose to open up new third-party accessory opportunities. Or maybe it’s just because I live in the most arid and cold city in Canada and holding on to an Apple Pencil with cold, dry hands is damn near impossible. I wish the shaft had some texture and was slightly wider; and perhaps not round but hexagonal like a real pencil.

But these rubber things are a cheap solution to the design shortcomings of the device.

Performance-wise, the Pencil performs about as well as the old Surface Pro 2. It’s better than the newer Surface Pro models, because the newer N-Trig digitizers that are in the Surface Pro 3 and 4 aren’t as good as the Wacom digitizer in earlier models.

But the Apple Pencil’s performance depends a lot on how developers have enabled support for the Pencil in their apps. Like, in the notebook app Outline, the Pencil is nearly useless. But in another notebook app, Good Notes, it’s impeccable; the Pencil is glorious.

So it seems that the Pencil is a great device, but app developers really have to work to correctly implement support for it.

It’s early days though for the Pencil. Overall, it’s a tremendously positive start. I just hope Apple improves on the physical design or lets third parties develop pencil devices. And I really look forward to how app developers will improve on what’s already a really good experience.